eRapport

DHECARE - Dhulikhel Emergency Care study - PhD

Prosjekt
Prosjektnummer
46056902
Ansvarlig person
Samita Giri
Institusjon
NTNU, ISB
Prosjektkategori
Doktorgradsstipend
Helsekategori
Cardiovascular, Infection, Injuries and Accidents
Forskningsaktivitet
8. Health Services
Rapporter
2019 - sluttrapport
Emergency diseases or conditions contribute to substantial disease burden, disabilities and deaths. Globally in 2015, 28.3 million deaths were due to emergency medical diseases, and the burden in low-income countries (LICs) is 4.4 times that of high-income countries (HICs). However, emergency health care systems in many LICs, and in Nepal, are underdeveloped. Knowledge of emergency patient characteristics is essential to consolidating and strengthening emergency health care systems. Despite this necessity, few reports have provided high-quality data regarding the emergency population in Nepal. This project aimed to describe the characteristics of emergency patients presented to Dhulikhel Hospital (DH) in Nepal. In addition, we aimed to evaluate mortality at 90 days after emergency care and associated mortality risk factors. We established an electronic emergency patient registry system and introduced a triage system to the emergency department (ED) of DH. Patients seeking emergency care from September 2013 to December 2016 and registered into the emergency patient registry were included in the study. Patient households were followed up at 90 days after emergency care to assess mortality after emergency care by structured telephone interviews. In the first study, we assessed the burden of emergency patients to DH during the 2015 earthquakes in Nepal. We observed a high caseload in the first few days, and the patient burden was particularly high before the international field hospitals were established. The proportions of severely injured patients and hospital mortality were relatively low, indicating that the most severely injured patients probably did not reach the hospital. The implementation of the simplified triage system was used for patient management and timely treatment according to severity. In the second study, we described characteristics of adult patients seeking emergency care at DH and assessed mortality at 90 days after emergency care. We observed that nearly one-third of the patients presented with injuries and that the majority of these were young men. Mortality after emergency care was more than 20-fold the ED mortality. Nearly one in four patients with respiratory and cardiovascular complaints died within 90 days after emergency care. The highest mortality was in individuals with chronic lung disease. Illiteracy and exposure to both tobacco smoke and traditional cooking stoves were strong determinants for mortality after emergency care in women but not in men. The third study describes patient characteristics, distribution of triage categories and mortality at 90 days after emergency care in children (≤16 years) at DH. The majority of paediatric emergencies were injuries and infections. Emergency health care-seeking among girls was less frequent compared to boys, but mortality after emergency care was higher among girls and among infants. Red and orange triage categories were strongly associated with intensive care treatment and mortality after emergency care. This study was performed in a Nepalese hospital, and, to our knowledge, it is the first study to describe in detail the characteristics and severity of a large number of patients seeking emergency care in Nepal. The findings from this study highlight the need to strengthen local health care systems to ensure that they are capable of managing natural disasters such as earthquakes while also maintaining adequate regular medical care. The high proportions of injured patients in a relatively young population underline a need to prioritize injury prevention programs at national levels and to strengthen organized trauma services in health care facilities. Our findings on mortality after emergency care are new and indicate an urgent need for more follow-up studies in similar settings. The local experience may support the use of triage systems, the need to establish follow-up systems after hospital discharge and the need for interventions that can reduce mortality after emergency care. The information provided by the current project may be used to develop cost-effective interventions, better resource allocation, infrastructure development, training needs, and inferences for policymakers to standardize ED and underlines a need for investments in strengthening the health care system. Research-based knowledge must be used by policymakers, health care providers and managers. This project highlights the need to strengthen emergency health care beyond ED care and for further studies that include multiple sites.
2018
Death rates and disability-adjusted life-years attributable to emergency conditions are three times higher in low-income countries compared to high-income countries. Data that analyses emergency health care needs in these settings are scarce. We have seeked to fill in on the knowledge gap on emergency care populations in a low resource setting.Summary of results Almost one third of the patients were injuries followed by abdominal complaints and infections. Respiratory and cardiovascular complaints together were less than 15%. More than half of the patients were young below the age of 45 years, and the majority of the patients seeking emergency care were from rural regions. Falls from heights was the most common cause of injury followed by traffic injuries. Very little evidence exists on mortality after emergency care in low-resource countries. We found that mortality within 90 days of hospital discharge was more than 20 times higher the hospital mortality. The mortality was much higher in the older age group (≥60 years). Although injuries, abdominal complaints and infections dominated this emergency population, patients with respiratory and cardiovascular complaints had particularly a high mortality. We found illiteracy independently associated with increased mortality at 90 days in women but not in men. Moreover women being both exposed to tobacco-smoking and traditional cooking stove were associated with higher 90-days mortality compared to no smoke exposure. Patient discharge initiated by family members was strongly associated with mortality at 90-days. Many different factors likely contributed to the high post-discharge mortality that we observed. These results suggest a need to develop post-discharge care systems that would likely reduce long-term mortality in emergency patients. This study provides information that can support improvement of the emergency health care system and implementation of cost-effective interventions. The summary of the results submitted above is from the third paper describing the emergency adult population at a local hospital in Nepal and is submitted to an international journal but not published (currently under revision) Publications and updates of the project: - First paper "Non-communicable diseases at a regional hospital in Nepal: Findings of a high burden of alcohol-related disease" published in international journal as second author. - Second paper "Impact of 2015 Earthquakes on a local hospital in Nepal: A Prospective Hospital-based Study" published in international journal as first author. - Third paper "Complaints and 90-days mortality in patients presenting to the emergency department at a hospital in Nepal" submitted in international journal as first author and is under revision. - Fourth paper: "Complaints and characteristics of pediatric patients presenting to the emergency department and 90-days mortality at a hospital in Nepal" Analysis is completed and manuscript is under Development. - Thesis is planned to defence at least by the end of 2019: writing is under progress - Submitted an invited article about the PhD project to forskining.no and is under revision
2017
Natural disasters pose a great challenge to the health systems and individual health facilities. In low-resource settings, disaster preparedness systems are often limited and not been well described. This study aims to describe the burden and distribution of emergency cases to a local hospital during the earthquake period in Nepal in 2015.Introduction In 2015, Nepal suffered from two earthquakes with magnitudes of 7.8 (April 25th) and 7.3 (May 12th) on the Richter scale. In total, close to 9,000 people were killed, 22,000 were injured, and 2,000,000 people were displaced from their homes. Approximately 90% of the health facilities in the affected areas were destroyed or severely damaged. The functioning health facilities were overwhelmed and there was shortage of medical supplies. As a result, the local health system ability to respond the health care needs in disaster-affected areas was compromised. Disaster preparedness is a key element to resilient health systems. Although considerable effort has been devoted to better disaster planning, there is still little evidence to support disaster planning and disaster risk reduction activities in low and middle-income countries. A national strategy for disaster risk management in Nepal does not include a separate plan for each type of disasters. Reports have stated that the national health information system of Nepal lack injury details from the earthquakes. The national disaster policy was often limited to the paper and was independent to the evidence. This can result in inadequate management of the patients. Study Result A total of 2,003 emergency patients were registered during the period. The average daily number of emergency patients during the first five days was almost five times higher (n=150) than the pre-incident daily average (n=35). The majority of injuries were fractures (58%), 348 (56%) in the lower extremities. A total of 345 surgical procedures were performed and the hospital treated 111 patients with severe injuries related to the earthquake (compartment syndrome, crush injury, and internal injury). Among those with follow-up interviews, over 90% reported that they had been severely affected by the earthquakes; complete house damage, living in temporary shelter, or loss of close family member. Conclusion Most EQIs arrived at the hospital within the first days after the first earthquake, and the local hospital treated a very high number of cases. The proportion of severely injured and in-hospital deaths were relatively low, probably indicating that the most severely injured did not reach the hospital. Most earthquake-affected regions in Nepal were rural and mountainous and there was continuous landslides, which affect transportation and prevent timely access to health facilities. The burden of emergency cases was high before the international field hospitals could be established. The international medical teams typically need some days after a disaster to initiate their services in the disaster affected areas. Until they arrive, patients are treated by the often poorly developed local health system, and many severely injured likely died prior to receiving medical treatment. The study underline the need for robust and easily available local health services that can respond to disasters such as an earthquake while also maintaining adequate medical care for other patients. The hospital staffs rapidly initiated systematic screening of patients arriving at the hospital using a simplified triage system, and prioritized effective surgical services. PMID:29394265 (Feb 2, 2018)
2016
Emergency Medicine is at top priority in the industralized country for improving quality and efficacy in medical care. However, emergency care seems to be neglected in low middle income countries like Nepal. The project seeks to improve emergency care through reorganize emergency department, train staffs and implement triage (sorting of patients).The aim of the study is to assess whether changes in the organization of emergency care including the implementation of a triage system and a systematic training program for staff, can reduce mortality and improve quality of care. Update per January 2017: • Post –intervention phase has been completed. • Total data that has been registered in electronic record system is approximately of 50,000 from discharge book and from emergency. • 30 days phone follow up was done for all these patients, among them we succeeded to interview nearly 10,000 patients where we collected socio-demographic information and outcome of the patients. • Triage in emergency room is well accepted and running smoothly. • Data of about 2,300 patients during 2015 eartquake has been collected and aiming for publication. • Phd Stipedent at NTNU taking courses and working on first paper Publication: • Non-Communicable disease at a regional hospital in Nepal: Findings of a high burden of alchol-related disease (has been phblished in Alcohol) October 2016, S Giri 3rd author. Other Planned Publication: (2016-2018) 1. The Burden of Disease in a Tertiary Level Hospital during the earthquake in Nepal 2015; A Retrospective Cohort Study (in the process for publication) S Giri 1st author. 2. Introduction of triage in the emergency room in Dhulikhel Hospital, Nepal: Evaluation of a quality improvement project. (June 2017) 3. The effect on patient's outcome after low-cost organizational changes in emergency care in an unselected population in Dhulikhel, Nepal. (June 2018)
2015
The last decade has put emergency medicine at top priority for improving quality and efficacy of medical care in industrialized countries. However, emergency care seems to have been a neglected topic in middle and low-income countries (MLIC). The project seeks to implement and evaluate strategies to improve emergency care in a low resource setting.The unique collaboration includes Kathmandu University School of Medical Sciences and Dhulikhel Hospital, The Clinic of Emergency Care and the Clinic of Pediatrics at St Olav Hospital, The Simulator Centre at NTNU/St. Olav, and the institutes of Public Health and Circulation and Imaging at NTNU. The aim of the study is to assess whether changes in the organization of emergency care including the implementation of a triage system and a systematic training program for staff, can reduce mortality and improve quality of care. Update per January 2016: • Pre –intervention phase has been completed. • Total data that has been registered in electronic record system is approximately of 22,000 from discharge book and from emergency. • 30 days phone follow up was done for all these patients, among them we succeeded to interview total 3000 patients where we collected socio-demographic information and outcome of the patients. Phase 2: Planning and implementation of intervention • Paramedics are trained in simulation training and RETTS triage system. RETTS Triage system has been implemented in ER since Nov 2014. • Reconstruction of ER is done where we have one entry in ER through triage room and patients are distributed in different room according to triage category. Red patients are treated in shock room, orange and yellow zone patients treated in one room and green/stable patients in green zone. Staffs at ER (medical officers and paramedics/nurses) are posted in different zones according to the need of the zones. Phase 3 • Completed the electronic registration of the patients from Sept-Dec 2015 for the ER patients (4000 patients). Discharge data are remained to be entered. Plan is to complete the registration and interviews by June 2016. • Intervention of triage, complete patients information records and reconstruction in ER is maintained and is progressive. • During the intervention phase of triage there was devastating earthquake in Nepal on 25th of April 2015. It was a good lesson learned by the team in hospital the importance of triage and disaster preparedness. Immediately on the second day of earthquake triage there was meeting with the different team at hospital and triage was done at the gate but not exactly that we are using now in ER- RETTS triage but we sorted the earthquake victims at the gate looking at the case, chief complain and type of fractures and using different colors ribbons. It has made the work more efficient for the medical team at the hospital in managing the patients. Publication 1: Burden of chronic diseases in 18 000 hospitalized cases in an unselected population in Dhulikhel, Nepal (has been submitted for publication in Globalization and Health) January 2016, S Giri 2nd author. Planned Publication: (2016-2018) 1. Use of triage and emergency care in the acute management of victims of earthquake in Nepal 2015. Lessons learned, the role of local hospital in Nepal. (Dec 2016) 2. Introduction of triage in the emergency room in Dhulikhel Hospital, Nepal: Evaluation of a quality improvement project. (June 2017) 3. The effect on patient's outcome after low-cost organizational changes in emergency care in an unselected population in Dhulikhel, Nepal. (June 2018)
Vitenskapelige artikler
Giri S, Rogne T, Uleberg O, Skovlund E, Shrestha SK, Koju R, Damås JK, Solligård E, Risnes KR

Presenting complaints and mortality in a cohort of 22 000 adult emergency patients at a local hospital in Nepal.

J Glob Health 2019 Dec;9(2):020403.

PMID: 31489186 - Inngår i doktorgradsavhandlingen

Giri S, Risnes K, Uleberg O, Rogne T, Shrestha SK, Nygaard ØP, Koju R, Solligård E

Impact of 2015 earthquakes on a local hospital in Nepal: A prospective hospital-based study.

PLoS One 2018;13(2):e0192076. Epub 2018 feb 2

PMID: 29394265 - Inngår i doktorgradsavhandlingen

Amundsen MS, Kirkeby TM, Giri S, Koju R, Krishna SS, Ystgaard B, Solligård E, Risnes K

Non-communicable diseases at a regional hospital in Nepal: Findings of a high burden of alcohol-related disease.

Alcohol 2016 Dec;57():9-14. Epub 2016 okt 20

PMID: 27916144

Deltagere
  • Samita Giri Doktorgradsstipendiat
  • Kari Ravndal Risnes Hovedveileder
  • Erik Solligård Prosjektleder

eRapport er utarbeidet av Sølvi Lerfald og Reidar Thorstensen, Regionalt kompetansesenter for klinisk forskning, Helse Vest RHF, og videreutvikles av de fire RHF-ene i fellesskap, med støtte fra Helse Vest IKT

Alle henvendelser rettes til Helse Midt-Norge RHF - Samarbeidsorganet og FFU

Personvern  -  Informasjonskapsler