eRapport

Diabetes on the social media: health promotion intervention and behaviour analysis

Prosjekt
Prosjektnummer
HNF1370-17
Ansvarlig person
Elia Dolores Gabarron Hortal
Institusjon
Universitetssykehuset Nord-Norge HF
Prosjektkategori
Postdoktorstipend
Helsekategori
Metabolic and endocrine, Generic health relevance
Forskningsaktivitet
3. Prevention, 8. Health Services
Rapporter
2020 - sluttrapport
From the last two Delphi studies carried out with 5 experts in diabetes and health education, we have concluded that: - Experts strongly agree that it is necessary to provide more information to people affected with diabetes and also to their family members through social media. They think this information should be provided by patient organizations and their collaborating healthcare personnel. They also think that the public health service should allocate resources to this and involve people with diverse competences like communication experts, general practitioners, and diabetes specialists like nutritionists, diabetes nurses and endocrinologists. - Experts agree that social media could be good environments to provide health promotion contents to people affected with diabetes. The most important issue highlighted by the experts is that social media channels have the benefit that they might reach out to very many people (different groups; people in all ages use these channels every day). They are easy to access. The information is available when you need it (always at hand). Experts are also worried about the validity and reliability of posted content. - Experts would recommend healthcare authorities the use of social media for diabetes-related health promotion. They think healthcare authorities could have their own social media for sharing information and answering questions By monitoring of all social media posts published in Diabetesforbundet channels (Facebook, Twitter and Instagram) during 3-years period (2017-2019, we have found that: - Regarding engagement with social media posts: A total of 1449 messages were posted. Posts of interviews and personal stories received 111% more likes, 106% more comments, and 112% more shares than miscellaneous posts (all P<.001). Messages posted about awareness days and other celebrations were 41% more likely to receive likes than miscellaneous posts (P<.001). Conversely, posts on research and innovation received 31% less likes (P<.001), 35% less comments (P=.02), and 25% less shares (P=.03) than miscellaneous posts. Health education posts received 38% less comments (P=.003) but were shared 39% more than miscellaneous posts (P=.007). With regard to social media channel, Facebook and Instagram posts were both 35 times more likely than Twitter posts to receive likes, and 60 times and almost 10 times more likely to receive comments, respectively (P<.001). Compared to text-only posts, those with videos had 3 times greater chance of receiving likes, almost 4 times greater chance of receiving comments, and 2.5 times greater chance of being shared (all P<.001). Including both videos and emoji in posts increased the chances of receiving likes by almost 7 times (P<.001). Adding an emoji to posts increased their chances of receiving likes and being shared by 71% and 144%, respectively (P<.001). - Social support & posts dealing with health education and physical activity promotion analysis: A total of 260 posts specifically dealing with health education (n=200) and physical activity promotion (n=60) were published along 3 years. Posts promoting physical activity received 54% more likes than posts on health education (p<0.05), but they were also 69% less likely to receive comments and be shared (both p<0.01). Posts that expressed two or more types of social support were the most engaging (received 3 times more likes, 2 times more comments, and over 6 times more shares, all p<0.001). Furthermore, posts that expressed tangible assistance received 6 times more likes (p<0.001), and the ones expressing network support almost 11 times more shares (p<0.05). The project had 2 additional media publications: - In Forskning.no: Article available at http://shorturl.at/dtuvI - In Science Nordic: Article available at http://shorturl.at/jszVX The use of social media to provide health education and health promotion to people with diabetes and their family members should be regarded as a supplementary health service: - Through 3 Delphi studies carried out in this project, health professionals, experts in diabetes and health education from Norway agree that it is necessary to provide more information to people affected with diabetes and also to their family members. They think that social media could be good environments to provide health promotion contents to people with diabetes. And they would recommend healthcare authorities the use of social media for diabetes-related health promotion. - Patient associations and patient groups from around the world are increasingly more present on social media. Being both ubiquitous and freely accessible, social media channels allow patient associations to share content and connect with individuals interested in their health condition while providing social support. This project has been carried out in collaboration with Diabetesforbundet, the main diabetes association in Norway. By January 2021, the association had almost 36,000 followers on Facebook, almost 8000 followers on Instagram, and more than 3000 followers on Twitter. - Users of the diabetes social media groups responded in a survey they are interested in health promotion contents delivered through social media. They say they are especially interested in knowing more about research and innovations in diabetes, in receiving contents in text format, and in finding the contents on Facebook. - A total of 260 posts specifically dealing with health education and physical activity promotion were published during the 3-years period in the three channels from the patient association (Facebook, Twitter and Instagram). - By monitoring social media posts from the patient association during a 3-years period we have found that diabetes social media users seem to be least engaged in posts with content topics that a priori could be linked to greater empowerment (i.e., research and innovation on diabetes, and health education). According to our findings we can recommend to diabetes social media groups, public health authorities, and other stakeholders interested in sharing research and innovation content and promoting health education on social media to consider including videos and emoji in their posts, and to publish on popular and visual-based social media channels, such as Facebook and Instagram, to increase user engagement. Our findings also suggest that the engagement on health education and physical activity promotion contents can be increased by expressing two or more types of social support within social media posts, by providing tangible assistance and network support, and by posting contents on Facebook and Instagram.

During the last year of the postdoc the interaction with the user representatives has mostly focused on discussion of the findings from this study.

2019
* One work package is completed, and one more is ongoing. * Several study related publications: 2 articles published in Level-1 journals; 2 scientific conference’ presentations, and 2 press releases. * Two additional communications have been submitted and are already accepted to be presented in conferences in 2020.1- STUDY PROGRESS: Work package 6 “Monitoring online behaviours on social media” and work package 7 “Assessment of the health promotion intervention and health professionals' involvement“ are ongoing. During this year it has been completed the data extraction of all posts from the three Diabetesforbundet social media channels (Facebook, Twitter and Instagram) that were published between 2017 and 2019. In addition to the posted’ contents, the posting date and the social media impact (likes, comments, and shares of each post) have also been extracted. Each post has been classified according to the contents’ type (i.e., diabetes-related technologies; research and innovation on diabetes; health education contents; exercise promotion; interviews/personal stories; diabetes awareness/celebrations; food recipes). Posts have also been classified according to the day of the week in which it was published. The data are being analyzed at the moment in close collaboration with members from Diabetesforbundet. During 2020 the data will be assessed through the opinion of both, panel of experts and social media users. 2- ADDITIONAL STUDY RELATED COMMUNICATIONS: - Preliminary results from diabetes’ social media posts show that health education contents (i.e., learn self-management, self-monitoring) were the most shared type of content (p<0,05). A remarkable significant low engagement around exercise promotion’ contents was also found, being this kind of contents both the least liked, shared, and commented (p<0,05). These preliminary analyses suggest that social media users engage considerably in health education content posted on social media, but not in exercise promotion’ posts. Since physical activity is very relevant for diabetes, exercise promotion’ content posted on social media should be presented in different ways to be more engaging. These results have already been accepted to be presented at 13th International Conference on Advanced Technologies & Treatments for Diabetes in February 2020. Authors of this presentation: Elia Gabarron, Eirik Årsand. Presentation title: Engagement in diabetes health education content on Facebook. - Another communication has been accepted to be presented during the Medical Informatics Europe conference in April 2020 “Social Media as a channel to understand patient needs”. This presentation will be done by Elia Gabarron during the Panel session on "Patient-Generated Data for Clinical Research and Practice". In addition to the reported research articles that have been published, during 2019, the project' dissemination also included: - An oral presentation at the Diabetes Forum 2019. Presenter: Elia Gabarron. Presentation title: The Delphi study. Creating a health promotion intervention on diabetes. - A poster presentation at 12th International Conference on Advanced Technologies & Treatments for Diabetes. Authors: Elia Gabarron, Berglind Fjola Smaradottir, Eirik Årsand. Presentation title: Health promotion priorities for diabetes: Results of a Delphi study. This communication can also be found in the journal Diabetes Technology and Therapeutics 2019;21(Suppl 1):316. - And 2 press releases, on the sentiment analysis of tweets related to diabetes: "Twitter avslørte en mer positiv holdning til diabetes type 1 enn type 2" published in Forskning.no [Internett] 2019-01-23; and "Twitter revealed a more positive attitude towards type 1 diabetes" published in Science Nordic [Internett] 2019-02-13.

During 2019, the postdoctoral researcher Elia Gabarron had a regular interaction with user representatives, i.e., Diabetesforbundet' staff members. As this research project is based on a participatory health approach, Diabetesforbundet' staff participation is decisive. Users representatives are very active in the creation of the contents of the health promotion intervention. They are distributing health promotion contents through their social media channels (Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram). They are involved in data analyses.

2018
* Three work packages completed, one more is ongoing. * Several study related publications: 2 articles published in Level-2 journals; 2 articles published in Level-1 journals; 2 press releases; and conferences presentations. * Study participants became Guest Editors of a Special issue on Social Media (Journal of Diabetes and Science Technology).1-STUDY PROGRESS: - Work package 1 "Identifying Social media users’ interests and preferences" completed. Questionnaires to identify Diabetesforbundet social media users’ main topics of interest and preferences were distributed through the 3 Diabeesforbundet' social media channels (Facebook, Twitter and Instagram) using LimeSurvey. The questionnaire was answered by 346 participants. Results of this questionnaire are published in manuscript with PMID:30538433, and in two press releases. - Work Package 2 "Health promotion intervention content – Panel of Experts" completed. A panel of 5 Norwegian experts in diabetes (1 diabetologist and 4 diabetes nurses) was established. The panellists reached consensus on the health promotion priorities for people affected with diabetes following the Delphi methods. Results of this Delphi study will be presented at the 12th International Conference on Advanced Technologies & Treatments for Diabetes (ATTD 2019). - Work Package 3 "Social media monitoring system establishment" completedm covering Diabetesforbundet social media channels (Facebook, Twitter and Instagram). - Work Package 4 "Health promotion intervention" in progress. Health promotion contents based on the results obtained in WP1 and WP2 are created in collaboration with researchers, panel of experts' members, UNN' communication department' staff, and Diabetesforbundet' staff. The contents are being distributed through social media. 2-ADDITIONAL STUDY RELATED COMMUNICATIONS: In addition to the four reported published research papers in 2018: - Press release "Helseråd på Facebook hjelper folk med diabetes" publishd in forskning.no, 10 October 2018, link: https://bit.ly/2Rh4vsJ - Press release "Diabetes patients want more information about research" published in ScienceNordic, 7 November 2018, link: https://bit.ly/2TcsXsI - Journal Paper "What are diabetes patients versus healthcare personnel discussing on social media?" (Årsand E, Bradway M, Gabarron E.) has been submitted and is under review. - Journal Paper "A systematic review of Artificial Intelligence for Participatory Health: Applications, Impact and Future Implications" (Denecke K, Gabarron E, Grainger R, Househ M, Konstantinidis S, Lau A, Rivera O, Miron-Shatz T, Merolli M.) has been submitted and is under review. - Panel "Participatory health and the future of co-created eHealth" was lead by Elia Gabarron at the Medical Informatics Europe Conference, Goteborg, 24-26 April. - Elia Gabarron was invited speaker at the Round table "Drivers and Barriers for a Paradigm Shift in Health" at the 1st Int Research Conference on eHealth and eWell-being, Barcelona 26 January. - Report "Social Media in Public Health" (Gabarron E; Fernandez-Luque L; Parrado JM; Bamidis PD; deBronkart D; Garcia-Puente M; Giunti G; Hullin C; Lau AYS; Laranjo L; Mayer MA; Petersen C; Salminen J) ordered by the Panamerican Health Organization, World Health Organization -WHO-PAHO- is expected to be published in 2019. 3-OTHER: - Postdoctoral researcher Elia Gabarron finished her stay abroad at Salumedia/University of Seville in June. - Postdoctoral researcher Elia Gabarron was organization committee' member of the 1st International Workshop on Participatory Health Informatics, carried out in Seville, 4-8 June. - Three study participants (Årsand E, Gabarron E, Bradway M) became Guest Editors of the Special issue on Social Media, Journal of Diabetes and Science Technology, expected to be published in 2019.

During 2018, the postdoctoral researcher Elia Gabarron had a regular interaction with user representatives, i.e., Diabetesforbundet' staff members. As this research project is based on a participatory health approach, Diabetesforbundet' staff participation is decisive: 1) they were very active to create the questions to be used in the questionnaire to know the social media users' preferences and interests on a health promotion intervention targeting them; 2) they were helping to disseminate the questionnaire through their three social media channels (Facebook, Twitter and Instagram); 3) they are very active in the creation of the contents of the health promotion intervention; 4) they are helping in the distribution of the health promotion contents through their social media channels.

2017
The aim of this project is to research how to best use social media to promote healthy lifestyles with and within the Norwegian diabetes population. The design of the health promotion intervention will be participatory, and will involve both a panel of healthcare experts and social media users from the Norwegian Diabetes Assoc. (Diabetesforbundet).1-STUDY PROGRESS: 1.1.Ethical issues: - The study protocol was submitted and it has assessed by the Norwegian Regional Ethics Committee, REK-Sør-Øst, with the reference code: 2017/764C, and it was declared exempt. - The treatment of personal information in this project has been approved by Data Protection Officer (Personvernombudet) at the University Hospital of North Norway (Nr. 0720). 1.2.Questionnaires: Social media users following the Diabetesforbundet were invited to actively participate in the definition of the health promotion intervention by expressing their opinions through an adhoc online questionnaire regarding their preferred contents; contents’ format (text, images and/or video); contents’ frequency; and preferred social media channels where to find these contents. The online questionnaire was designed on LimeSurvey, and it was posted on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram in November 2017. A total of 346 questionnaires were answered in one week (332 reached the questionnaire from Facebook; 14 from Instagram; and 0 from Twitter). A manuscript reporting the results of these questionnaires has been sent to both, Diabetesforbundet, and Medical Informatics Europe congress -MIE2018-. 1.3.Panel of experts is being arranged. 2-ONGOING MANUSCRIPTS: - Study protocol paper "Social media for health promotion in diabetes: study protocol for a participatory public health intervention design" (Gabarron E; Bradway M; Fernandez-Luque L; Chomutare T; Hansen AH; Wynn R; Årsand E) has been submitted to BMC Health Services Research on 10th November 2017 (awaiting for editorial feedback). - Paper "Diabetes social media users’ preferences for a health promotion intervention" (Gabarron E; Dorronzoro E; Rivera O; Årsand E) submitted to MIE2018 conference (awaiting for feedback). - Paper "Participatory health and the future of co-created eHealth" (Gabarron E; Merolli M; Petersen C; Bamidis PD; Martin-Sanchez F) submitted to MIE2018 conference (awaiting for feedback). - Report "Social Media in Public Health" (Gabarron E; Fernandez-Luque L; Parrado JM; Bamidis PD; deBronkart D; Garcia-Puente M; Giunti G; Hullin C; Lau AYS; Laranjo L; Mayer MA; Petersen C; Salminen J) for Panamerican Health Organization, World Health Organization -WHO-PAHO- (expected publication: first semester 2018). 3-PUBLISHED: - Poster presented at Cyberpsychology Congress -Cypsy22-. Poster: "Healthcare representatives tweeting about #diabetes: Follow the leaders!" (Gabarron E; Armayones M; Garcia P; Wynn R; Årsand E). - Panel held at Medical Informatics Congress -MedInfo 2017-. Panel:"When social media do not deliver as intended in health: Considerations and possible solutions for dealing with undesirable outcomes" (Merolli M; Fernandez-Luque L; Denecke K; and Gabarron E). - Report "Sosial, digital kontakt" (Gabarron E; Hoaas H; Johnsen E) for Helsedirektoratet, ISBN: 978-82-8242-065-5. - Speaker at workshop "Identifying patient needs" (Jornada Sabien Periscopio) held in Valencia (Spain) on the 25th October 2017. 4-OTHER: - Stay abroad at Salumedia/University of Seville started on 2nd September - Published paper due to stay abroad collaboration: "Mobile Phone Apps for Quality of Life and Well-Being Assessment in Breast and Prostate Cancer Patients: Systematic Review" (Rincon E; Monteiro-Guerra F; Rivera-Romero O; Dorronzoro-Zubiete E; Sanchez-Bocanegra CL; Gabarron E) JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2017 Dec; 5(12): e187.
Vitenskapelige artikler
Gabarron E, Larbi D, Dorronzoro E, Hasvold PE, Wynn R, Årsand E

Factors Engaging Users of Diabetes Social Media Channels on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram: Observational Study.

J Med Internet Res 2020 09 29;22(9):e21204. Epub 2020 sep 29

PMID: 32990632

Larbi D, Randine P, Årsand E, Antypas K, Bradway M, Gabarron E

Methods and Evaluation Criteria for Apps and Digital Interventions for Diabetes Self-Management: Systematic Review.

J Med Internet Res 2020 07 06;22(7):e18480. Epub 2020 jul 6

PMID: 32628125

Bradway M, Gabarron E, Johansen M, Zanaboni P, Jardim P, Joakimsen R, Pape-Haugaard L, Årsand E

Methods and Measures Used to Evaluate Patient-Operated Mobile Health Interventions: Scoping Literature Review.

JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2020 04 30;8(4):e16814. Epub 2020 apr 30

PMID: 32352394

Årsand E, Bradway M, Gabarron E

What Are Diabetes Patients Versus Health Care Personnel Discussing on Social Media?

J Diabetes Sci Technol 2019 03;13(2):198-205. Epub 2019 jan 13

PMID: 30636445

Gabarron E, Dorronzoro E, Rivera-Romero O, Wynn R

Diabetes on Twitter: A Sentiment Analysis.

J Diabetes Sci Technol 2019 May;13(3):439-444. Epub 2018 nov 19

PMID: 30453762

Gabarron E, Bradway M, Fernandez-Luque L, Chomutare T, Hansen AH, Wynn R, Årsand E

Social media for health promotion in diabetes: study protocol for a participatory public health intervention design.

BMC Health Serv Res 2018 06 05;18(1):414. Epub 2018 jun 5

PMID: 29871675

Gabarron E, Årsand E, Wynn R

Social Media Use in Interventions for Diabetes: Rapid Evidence-Based Review.

J Med Internet Res 2018 Aug 10;20(8):e10303. Epub 2018 aug 10

PMID: 30097421

Gabarron E, Dorronzoro E, Bradway M, Rivera-Romero O, Wynn R, Årsand E

Preferences and interests of diabetes social media users regarding a health-promotion intervention.

Patient Prefer Adherence 2018;12():2499-2506. Epub 2018 nov 23

PMID: 30538433

Rincon E, Monteiro-Guerra F, Rivera-Romero O, Dorronzoro-Zubiete E, Sanchez-Bocanegra CL, Gabarron E

Mobile Phone Apps for Quality of Life and Well-Being Assessment in Breast and Prostate Cancer Patients: Systematic Review.

JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2017 Dec 04;5(12):e187. Epub 2017 des 4

PMID: 29203459

Marco-Ruiz L, Bønes E, de la Asunción E, Gabarron E, Aviles-Solis JC, Lee E, Traver V, Sato K, Bellika JG

Combining multivariate statistics and the think-aloud protocol to assess Human-Computer Interaction barriers in symptom checkers.

J Biomed Inform 2017 Oct;74():104-122. Epub 2017 sep 9

PMID: 28893671

Gabarron E, Bradway M, Årsand E.

Social media for adults.

Diabetes Digital Health. Elsevier 2020. ISBN: 978-0-12-817485-2

Gabarron E, Årsand E.

Engagement in diabetes health education content on Facebook.

Diabetes Technol Ther 2020; 22, A154.

Bradway M, Larbi D, Randine P, Antypas K, Gabarron E, Årsand E

Intervention studies need to adapt to address patient needs for diabetes self-management.

Diabetes Technol Ther 2020; 22, A229.

Gabarron E, Larbi D, Årsand E, Wynn R.

Engaging social media users with health education and physical activity promotion.

Submitted to Studies in Health Technology and Informatics (January 2021)

Gabarron E, Fernandez-Luque L, Schopf TR, Lau AYS, Armayones M, Wynn R, Serrano JA.

Impact of Facebook Ads for Sexual Health Promotion Via an Educational Web App: A Case Study.

Int J E-Health Med Comm 2017;8(2):18-32.

Wynn R, Oyeyemi S, Johnsen JA, Gabarron E.

Tweets are not always supportive of patients with mental disorders.

Int J Integrated Care 2017; 17(3):A149.

Doktorgrader
Elia Dolores Gabarron Hortal

Social media and sexual health

Disputert:
mai 2017
Hovedveileder:
Jose Artur Serrano
Deltagere
  • Eirik Årsand Prosjektleder
  • Håvard Kvalvåg Blixgård Prosjektdeltaker
  • Meghan Bradway Prosjektdeltaker
  • Taridzo Chomutare Prosjektdeltaker
  • Luis Fernandez Luque Prosjektdeltaker
  • Anne Helen Hansen Prosjektdeltaker
  • Tea Kristiansen Prosjektdeltaker
  • Rolf Wynn Prosjektdeltaker
  • Elia Dolores Gabarron Hortal Postdoktorstipendiat

eRapport er utarbeidet av Sølvi Lerfald og Reidar Thorstensen, Regionalt kompetansesenter for klinisk forskning, Helse Vest RHF, og videreutvikles av de fire RHF-ene i fellesskap, med støtte fra Helse Vest IKT

Alle henvendelser rettes til eRapport, Helse Nord

Personvern  -  Informasjonskapsler